The Best Places to Eat on Madeline Island

Madeline Island, the largest of the Apostle Islands, is not just known for its stunning natural beauty but also for its unique and diverse dining scene. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, comforting pizza, or a quirky open-air bar, the island has something to satisfy every craving. Here’s a list of the best places to eat on Madeline Island, complete with links to their websites.

1. The Pub Restaurant and Wine Bar

Located at The Inn on Madeline Island, The Pub offers an elevated dining experience with stunning lakeside views. Their menu features regional favorites like Lake Superior trout and whitefish, as well as steaks, seafood, and stone-hearth pizzas. Pair your meal with a selection from their full wine and beer list or enjoy a handcrafted island-inspired cocktail.

Website: The Pub Restaurant and Wine Bar

2. Beach Club

Situated near the ferry dock, the Beach Club is the perfect spot for casual dining with incredible lake views. Their menu includes a variety of American classics, from burgers to fish sandwiches, and they offer both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s a great spot for a relaxed meal while soaking in the island vibe.

Website: Beach Club

3. Grampa Tony’s

A family-friendly favorite, Grampa Tony’s is known for its delicious pizzas, hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, and breakfast options. Don’t forget to stop by for their ice cream—look for the giant ice cream cone on Main Street to guide you there.

Website: Grampa Tony’s

4. Farmhouse Kitchen

If you’re looking for locally sourced ingredients and a cozy atmosphere, Farmhouse Kitchen is a must-visit. They offer breakfast and lunch options, including vegan and vegetarian dishes, making it a great choice for health-conscious diners.

Website: Farmhouse Kitchen

5. Café Seiche

For an intimate dining experience, head to Café Seiche. Known for its farm-to-table approach, the menu changes seasonally to highlight fresh, local ingredients. This charming restaurant is perfect for a relaxed dinner with a creative twist.

Website: Café Seiche

6. Tom’s Burned Down Café

Quirky, iconic, and truly unique, Tom’s Burned Down Café is an open-air bar with a laid-back vibe. Known for its eclectic decor, live music, and cold drinks, this spot is a must-visit for those looking to experience the island’s fun and artistic side. They occasionally offer light snacks or food truck options.

Website: Tom’s Burned Down Café

7. Mission Hill Coffee

Start your day with a cup of coffee or a fresh pastry from Mission Hill Coffee. This quaint café is the perfect spot to fuel up before exploring the island or to enjoy a quiet moment in the middle of your adventures.

Website: Mission Hill Coffee

Madeline Island’s dining scene reflects its charm and character, offering options for every taste and mood. Whether you’re enjoying a fine meal with a view or grabbing a quick bite after exploring, these establishments are sure to make your visit even more memorable.

Plan your island adventure today and savor the best of Madeline Island’s culinary delights!